
When a business borrower defaults on a commercial loan, the collateral rarely covers the full balance. The personal guaranty signed by the company’s owner is often what allows a lender to recover the rest. At Murray | Lobb Attorneys, we have represented financial institutions, businesses, and real estate investors in Texas since 1991, and we regularly help lenders collect on guaranties when a loan goes bad. A guaranty is only as strong as its wording, and Texas law tends to favor lenders whose documents anticipate the defenses that guarantors most often raise.
What Does a Personal Guaranty Do?
A personal guaranty is a promise by an individual, usually an owner or officer of the borrowing company, to pay the company’s debt if the company does not. Because the company itself is typically an LLC or corporation that shields its owners from business debts, the guaranty is what puts the owner’s personal assets within the lender’s reach.
Texas requires a personal guaranty to be in writing. Because the borrowing company is a separate legal entity, a personal guaranty is a promise to answer for another’s debt, even if the owner thinks of the loan as personal. Under the statute of frauds in Texas Business and Commerce Code Section 26.01, that promise is generally unenforceable unless it is in a signed writing. Oral assurances from an owner that “I’ll make sure you get paid” rarely support a claim.
Guaranty of Payment vs. Guaranty of Collection
The single most important term in many guaranties is whether the guarantor promised payment or collection.
- Guaranty of payment: The guarantor’s obligation is primary. Once the borrower defaults, the lender may sue the guarantor directly without first suing the borrower or foreclosing on collateral.
- Guaranty of collection: The guarantor is liable only after the lender has exhausted its remedies against the borrower. The lender usually must obtain a judgment against the borrower and show that it could not be collected.
Most commercial lenders require guaranties of payment for this reason. If the document is unclear, the guarantor will argue that it is a guaranty of collection, which can significantly delay recovery.
What Must a Lender Prove to Enforce a Guaranty?
To recover on a guaranty in Texas, a lender generally must establish:
- The existence and ownership of the guaranty
- The terms of the underlying loan
- That any conditions to the guarantor’s liability have occurred
- That the guarantor failed or refused to perform
Well-drafted guaranty cases are often resolved on summary judgment, supported by the loan documents, the guaranty, and an affidavit establishing the default and the amount owed. Lenders should keep a clean record of assignments, since a guarantor will challenge standing if the loan has changed hands.
Defenses Guarantors Raise and How Waivers Answer Them
Guarantors frequently claim they were released because the lender extended the maturity date, changed the interest rate, or released collateral without their consent. Under traditional suretyship principles, a material change to the underlying obligation can discharge the guarantor. Most modern commercial guaranties address this by stating that the guarantor consents in advance to modifications, extensions, and releases.
Texas also gives sureties a statutory tool. Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 43.002, once a debt is due, a surety may send the creditor a written notice requiring it to sue on the contract. If the creditor does not sue in the first term of court after receiving the notice (or the second term, if it shows good cause for the delay), or does not prosecute the suit to judgment and execution, the surety is discharged. Commercial guaranties commonly waive this right, and lenders should confirm their forms do.
The most valuable waiver often involves foreclosure deficiencies. Under Texas Property Code Section 51.003, a person sued for a deficiency after a nonjudicial foreclosure may ask the court to determine the property’s fair market value as of the sale date. If that value exceeds the foreclosure price, the deficiency is reduced by the difference. In Moayedi v. Interstate 35/Chisam Road, L.P., 438 S.W.3d 1 (Tex. 2014), the Texas Supreme Court held that a guarantor who waived all defenses in the guaranty also waived this offset. A broad, clearly written waiver can therefore preserve the full deficiency against the guarantor.
How Long Does a Lender Have to Sue a Guarantor?
A lender generally has four years to sue a guarantor on the guaranty, but under Section 51.003, a suit for a deficiency after a nonjudicial foreclosure sale must be brought within two years of the sale. Lenders pursuing a guarantor for a post-foreclosure shortfall should treat that two-year deadline as controlling.
The borrower’s bankruptcy also does not ordinarily put the case against the guarantor on hold. The automatic stay generally applies only to the debtor, so a lender can usually continue pursuing a guarantor while the borrower is in bankruptcy, unless the bankruptcy court extends protection in unusual circumstances.
Collecting the Judgment
Winning a judgment against a guarantor does not guarantee the lender will collect it. Texas has some of the strongest debtor exemptions in the country, including broad homestead protection and exemptions for certain personal property and retirement accounts. Community property rules can also limit recovery, because property under the sole management of a guarantor’s spouse is generally not reachable for the guarantor’s contractual debts. A lender should evaluate a guarantor’s non-exempt assets early, ideally before the loan is made, while keeping in mind that the Equal Credit Opportunity Act and Regulation B generally bar a lender from requiring a spouse to sign a guaranty or other credit document when the applicant qualifies individually.
Practical Steps for Lenders
- Confirm the guaranty is a guaranty of payment, not collection
- Review waivers, including consent to modifications, Chapter 43 rights, and the Section 51.003 offset
- Send a clear written demand to the guarantor after default
- Track the two-year deadline following any foreclosure sale
- Assess the guarantor’s assets and exemptions before filing suit
Speak With a Harris County Creditor Rights Attorney
A personal guaranty can turn a partial recovery into a full one, but only if it is drafted and enforced correctly. Whether you are preparing loan documents or pursuing a guarantor after default, Murray | Lobb Attorneys can review your guaranty, identify the defenses you are likely to face, and move quickly to protect your recovery. We serve clients throughout Harris, Galveston, Fort Bend, Montgomery, and Chambers Counties. Call 281-488-0630 or contact us to schedule a consultation with a Harris County creditor rights attorney.